Sour Cherry & Vanilla Frozen Yogurt Pops

Oh, hey! It’s another ice pop! These pops are the creamy, frozen yogurt variety, blended with tart sour cherries and bit of vanilla. The cherry-vanilla situation reminds me of the cherry push-pops of my youth…but more tart, more vanilla-y, and more better.

Yeah, they’re totes more better.

Since moving to Michigan I have become obsessed with sour cherries. They are mouth-puckering on their own, but a little sugar makes them sweet-tart and I find that they have an almost cinnamon-spice background flavor that just makes me crazy for them–dried, frozen, or jarred. The thing with sour cherries is that they can be tough to find. They’re the red gems you find in a classic cherry pie–sans pie goop. Even here in Michigan–a major sour cherry producer–I have never seen a fresh one. I get by just fine with whole, frozen sour cherries. The complex flavor of the cherries is perfectly matched with smooth vanilla, making this frozen treat a sure winner.

Sour Cherry & Vanilla Frozen Yogurt Pops

Makes 10 ice pops

I used non-fat greek yogurt here because it’s basically the only yogurt I buy. I also used homemade vanilla sugar–I keep a jar around or simply rub the guts of a vanilla bean into the sugar–if you don’t have a vanilla bean, stir 1-2 teaspoons of vanilla extract into the yogurt mixture. If you can only find dark, sweet cherries feel free to use those and add a tablespoon or so of lemon juice to the puree to brighten the sweetness…though, I urge you to find the sour ones if you can. They really are something special. 

2 cups plain greek yogurt

3/4 cups vanilla sugar, divided

8 ounces frozen sour cherries, defrosted, plus more cherries (20-30) for garnish

In a mixing bowl, combine yogurt with 1/2 cup of the vanilla sugar, stir to dissolve the sugar. Divide the mixture in hal between two bowls, set aside.

Puree the cherries with 1/4 cup of the sugar and any collected juices from defrosting. Press the cherry puree through a fine mesh sieve, pressing to extract as much as possible, discard solids left behind. Stir the cherry puree into one of the bowl of yogurt–leaving the other plain.

Fill the pop molds 1/3 full with the cherry-yogurt mixture, freeze for 30-60 minutes until the layer begins to set before adding the vanilla layer. In the vanilla layer, drop in 2-3 whole cherries reserved for garnish. Freeze the vanilla layer 30 minutes (this layer is more stable since it doesn’t have any puree and won’t need to set up long). Fill the pop molds with the final cherry-yogurt layer, add sticks, and freeze until solid–8 or more hours.



  1. says

    Beautiful! I’ve never been able to get my hands on the fresh sour cherries, either! What’s up with that? There’s an orchard nearby where I can pick them, but this summer they lost most of their crop and won’t be having the u-pick :( Some day!

  2. says

    This year there weren’t many sour cherries, but fresh ones can be found. If you go up north to Traverse City and the like, they’re everywhere in July, usually, though this year was an exception. There’s also a place called Spicer Orchards in Fenton. They have wonderful produce including fresh sour cherries. They aren’t the prettiest cherries, but last year I made muffins and a bundt cake with tremendous success. No more this year, but they’ll be back next year.

  3. says

    Cindy, you are on a roll with the popsicles! As someone who currently lives in the land of eternal summer, I am totally grateful. Keep ’em coming!

  4. says

    I was raised eating sour cherries – they grew along the ditch behind my grandparents house. I love sour cherries! I wish they were easier to find fresh.

  5. says

    These look delicious!

    Are the popsicle sticks still easy to put in after freezing the first two layers? Or should you put them in earlier and then pour in the other layers around them?

  6. Ivymae says

    I live in Cali and the sour cherries are abundant here!
    I can go down to the farmers market and choose home grown cherries by the pound.
    Maybe this recipe is for me!


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *